Scareapple Pie Value
Scareapple Pie is a legendary low tier hammer from the Halloween set in Flee the Facility. The community value is 5, which makes it the 239th most valuable of 458 tracked items and below the Halloween set average of 17.5.
- Value
- 5
- Demand
- 0.5/5 · Barely any
- Rarity
- Legendary
- Set
- Halloween
- Trend
- Stable
- Updated
- 2026-06-11
The matching gemstone
Scareapple Pie was released alongside Scareapple gemstone, which this value list does not track. The two halves of a pair trade separately, so one being cheap says nothing about the other.
Fair 1-for-1 trades for Scareapple Pie
Items within 10% of Scareapple Pie's value, closest match first.
| Item | Rarity | Value | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
 4th Anniversary | Legendary | 5 | +0 |
 5th Anniversary | Legendary | 5 | +0 |
 6th Anniversary | Legendary | 5 | +0 |
 Beach Boat | Legendary | 5 | +0 |
 Clown | Rare | 5 | +0 |
 Coastal Lighthouse | Legendary | 5 | +0 |
 Coral Reefs | Rare | 5 | +0 |
 Cuddly Bunny | Legendary | 5 | +0 |
Trade up from Scareapple Pie
The next items above it on the value ladder.
| Item | Rarity | Value | You add |
|---|---|---|---|
 Winter Breeze | Legendary | 6 | +1 |
 Unicorn Starlight | Common | 6 | +1 |
 Stack of Presents | Legendary | 6 | +1 |
 Shroomy | Legendary | 6 | +1 |
 Mycelium | Legendary | 6 | +1 |
 Jingle Bells | Legendary | 6 | +1 |
Trade down from Scareapple Pie
What sits just below it if you are taking a downgrade plus adds.
More Halloween items
Gothic Bouquet
Halloween
Pumpkin Slice
Halloween
Devilish Candle
Halloween
Spooky Brew
Halloween
Bleak Ink
Halloween
Batwing Basher
Halloween
Psycho Chainsaw
Halloween
DarkBone Crusher
HalloweenHow this value is set
Values on this page are community estimates collected from Flee the Facility traders, not official Roblox prices. Scareapple Pie was last reviewed on 2026-06-11. Demand matters as much as raw value: a high-value item with low demand can sit unsold for weeks, while a mid-tier item with steady demand moves quickly. Always compare both sides of a trade before you accept.